The Competent Authorities Should Agree That The Canadian TFSA Has The Same Treaty Status As The US Roth IRA

2018 Prologue

In 2018 I wrote a post arguing that it is reasonable to conclude that the text of the Canada US Tax Treaty should be interpreted to mean that a Canadian TFSA is – like a US ROTH IRA – a pension within the meaning of the Canada US Tax Treaty. The 2018 post was arguing for equal treatment without the intervention of the respective Canadian and American Competent Authorities.

The Punitive Taxation Of US Citizens Living Outside The United States Continues

I have previously and repeatedly made the point that:

Read More

A taxpayer who is a U.S. resident for purposes of a U.S. income tax treaty is generally entitled to request assistance from the U.S. “competent authority” where the actions of a treaty country or the United States would (i) cause double taxation or (ii) taxation that is inconsistent with the treaty.  Competent authority assistance is only available with respect to countries that have an applicable tax treaty with the United States.  Our Treaty Resource Page provides an overview of every U.S. tax treaty and the tax system of each such country.

A taxpayer seeking assistance from the U.S. competent authority should always first consult any applicable treaty articles, including the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) article, before requesting assistance.  In addition to filing a request for assistance with competent authority, the taxpayer should consider (i) filing a timely protective claim for credit or refund; and (ii) take any required actions that are necessary under the procedures of the foreign country to avoid losing the right to appeal or obtain competent authority review under that country’s income tax laws.

Read More