Ask Tax Question

The IRS requires mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding on distributions from 401k and 403b accounts... (See Question Below)

The IRS requires mandatory 20% federal income tax withholding on distributions from 401k and 403b accounts but not from an IRA-on these you have the option to determine the amount if any, to have withheld. Why does the IRS require federal tax withholding from 403b and 401k but not from an IRA.? For an IRA, tax to be withheld, if any, is at the discretion of the account holder.

Both are tax deferred accounts. For an IRA you get a deduction for AGI and for a 403b and 401k the contribution reduces salary included on the tax return.
Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs)
TaxConnections Members... Answer This Question Want To be One of Our Tax Experts? Register Here

Tax Professional Answers

User Photo
Caran Ebert, CPA
A 401(k) as well as 403(b) and 457 are "qualified" employer sponsored retirement plans, sometimes employers offer matching contributions up to a percentage of your salary. The money is pretax, a direct salary deduction, and stated on the W-2 issued by the employer. In 2015, you are allowed to contribute up to $18,000 of your income to a 401(k) and an additional $6,000 if you are over 50. The money in any of these retirement accounts and a traditional IRA can be deferred until you reach age 70 1/2. An IRA (Individual Retirement Account) is a self directed retirement account for people that work for companies that do not offer retirement plans that sometimes contains the rollover of a 401K and 403B when the employee changes jobs. For 2015 you can contribute $5,500 and $6,500 for those over 50. Legally, the 401(k) and 403(b) cannot be taken for debt or bankruptcy or tax liens because they are directly related to your wages and the law makes them untouchable; however, IRA's being self directed can be taken for any reason. You are in charge and you must self-direct the amount you want to withhold from the withdrawal of a traditional IRA account, where the government has laws in place that require at least 20% withholding on a withdrawal of a 401(k), 403(b), and 457 which are related to your wages. Please note that over the 30+ years that I have prepared taxes 20% withholding is not enough to pay the taxes you owe on the withdrawal of any retirement account at no matter what tax bracket you are in and especially if when you take the money you are not 59 1/2 because you would owe an additional 10% penalty for taking the money before the minimum age requirement for withdrawal.
Leave a Comment 90 weeks ago

User Photo
Harold Goedde
If you take a required minimum, distribution from a 403b account over a period of more than 10 years there is NO required federal withholding tax. Taxpayer can have as much taken out as desired, including nothing.
Leave a Comment 69 weeks ago

Meet Leading Tax Advisors

User Photo Kathryn Morgan

Bossier City, Louisiana, USA

Enrolled Agent, Master Tax Advisor

User Photo Peter J. Scalise

New York, New York, USA

Federal Tax Credits & Incentives Practice Leader

User Photo John Stancil

Lakeland, Florida, USA

Tax Advisor/CEO

User Photo John Dundon, II EA

Denver, Colorado, USA

Tax Director

User Photo Steven Potts JD EA IAR

Fullerton, California, USA


User Photo Devon McCarthy FCCA, EA

Sanford, Florida, USA


User Photo Caran Ebert, CPA

Topanga, California, USA

Tax Advisor

User Photo Lisa Nason CPA, MST

Greenville, South Carolina, USA

Managing Shareholder

User Photo Gary Carter, PhD, MT, CPA

Edina, Minnesota, USA



Santa Clara, California, USA

Tax Principal - President

User Photo Bill Robinson, CPA

Chattanooga, Tennessee, USA


User Photo Hugo Van Zyl

Stellenbosch, South Africa

Exchange Control & Master Tax Practitioner (SA)

User Photo Douglas Stransky

Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Tax Partner, International Tax

User Photo Larry Stolberg, CPA, CA

Toronto Mississauga Oakville Burlington Hamilton, Canada

Tax Specialist

User Photo Gerald Nordland

Phoenix, Arizona, USA


View/Select our Current List of Tax Topics

# A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Previous PageNext Page

Contact Us Today